Author Archives: craigidlebrook

Nov 23

Joy In the Act of Uplifting: “I AM”

Posted on by

Photo By Steven Pisano.

Presented by Celebrity Series of Boston
Choreography & Direction – Camille A. Brown
Inspired by the television show Lovecraft Country (Episode: “I Am”)
Original Music by Deah Love Harriott, Juliette Jones, Jaylen Petinaud, Martine Mauro-Wade, Frédérique Gnaman, Monique Brooks Roberts
Additional Music by Busta Rhymes, Crystal Waters, Dru Hill, Lil Kim ft. Lil Cease, Method Man ft. Mary J. Blige, Sounds of Blackness, The Temptations
Performed by Camille A. Brown & Dancers
Company – Dorse Brown, Mikhail Calliste, Nya Cymone Carter, Courtney Cook, Brianna Dawkins, Eboni Edwards, Mykal Kilgore, Kai Irby, Alain ‘Hurrikane’ Lauture, Chaz Ryan, Courtney Ross, Curtis Thomas, Travon Williams
Musicians: Juliette Jones, Martine Mauro-Wade, Meech

November 14–15, 2025
Cutler Majestic Theatre
219 Tremont Street
Boston, MA 02116

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

BOSTON — A smile can be infectious, and a sorrow shared becomes lighter. 

You would think you couldn’t fill up a theater with the musical and theatrical embodiment of these two sentiments for over an hour, but you’d be wrong. Continue reading →

Nov 11

A Family Affair: KIM’S CONVENIENCE

Posted on by

Ins Choi and Esther Chung in “Kim’s Convenience” (2025). Photo by Dahlia Katz

Adam Blanshay Productions presents the Soulpepper Theatre Company production in association with American Conservatory Theater
Presented by The Huntington
Written by Ins Choi
Director –  Weyni Mengesha
Cast –  Ins Choi, Kelly Seo, Esther Chung, Ryan Jinn, and Brandon McKnight
Set Design –  Joanna Yu
Costume Design – Ming Wong
Lighting Design –  Wen-Ling Liao
Video and Production Design – Nicole Eun-Ju Bell
Sound Design –  Fan Zhang

November 6–30, 2025
The Calderwood Pavilion
Boston Center for the Arts
527 Tremont Street
Boston, MA 02116

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

BOSTON — Some performers become known for and steeped in the same work for years. For a few unfortunate souls, often those only known for one thing, the work becomes a prison as well as a meal ticket, and you watch them grimly go through the motions of performance. For others, the work becomes like a family member the artist can nurture and watch grow; the work may cause them heartache at times, but they still can cradle it with love and find new wonder in it. I suspect playwright and actor Ins Choi’s feelings toward Kim’s Convenience, a play about an imperfect Korean-Canadian family, fall in the latter category, and that may be what makes his return to the stage in the play so poignant to watch.   Continue reading →

Sep 23

Still Sad, Lovely, and Alive: “Rent”

Posted on by

Aaron Alcaraz (Mark Cohen) and Austin Turner (Roger Davis) with the cast of “Rent.” Photos © Paul Lyden

Presented by North Shore Music Theatre
Book, Music, and Lyrics by Jonathan Larson
Direction and Choreography by Marcos Santana
Music direction by Robert L Rucinski
Musical Arrangements by Steve Skinner
Original Concept/Additional Lyrics by Billy Aronson

September 16 – September 28, 2025
North Shore Music Theatre
54 Dunham Rd.
Beverly, MA 01915

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

BEVERLY, Mass. — When I first heard that North Shore Music Theatre was staging a production of Rent, I was a bit surprised. After all, the theatre is more well-known for crowd-pleasing musicals that will appeal to an older audience than for edgy, newer shows like those I first saw in college. Then it hit me. Rent has long ago passed the realm of edgy or new, and I had just gotten my AARP card in the mail.

Rent first burst onto Broadway in 1996 and stunned many theatergoers with its frank and humane depictions of the LGBTQ+ community, the AIDs epidemic, and those struggling with addiction. Set in a decaying New York City in 1989, the rock musical refused to allow its characters to be afterschool special-shallow, either as heroes or as cautionary tales. They were complicated, flawed, and lovely. The play’s beating heart was its depiction of the power of found family among non-conformists. Continue reading →

Jul 29

Kafkaesque Comedy: “The Understudy”

Posted on by

Hub Theatre Co presents “The Understudy.”

Presented by The Hub Theatre Company of Boston
Written by Theresa Rebeck
Director – Paula Plum
Choreographer – Kiki Samko
Cast – Lauren Elias, Cristhain Mancinas-Garcia, Kevin Paquette

July 19 – August 2, 2025
Pay-What-You-Can Admission
Club Café
209 Columbus Ave.
Boston, MA 02116

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

BOSTON — Those who make the theatre their profession love to write about theatre as a profession. It’s an occupational hazard that audiences enjoy.

Playwright and author Theresa Rebeck is perhaps best known for penning the television show Smash, which premiered in 2012. The show followed the messy development process for a new musical and became something of a cult favorite during its two-season run. The play The Understudy, which Rebeck published in 2010, can feel a bit like a quiet prequel to Smash. The two works share themes about the push and pull between wanting to make great art and wanting to make it big. Continue reading →

Jul 13

Uneven Grandeur: “Evita”

Posted on by

The cast of “Evita.”

Presented by Reagle Music Theatre of Greater Boston
Lyrics by Tim Rice 
Music by Andrew Lloyd Webber
Direction and choreography – Rachel Bertone
Musical Direction – Dan Rodriguez
Scenic Design – Cameron McEachearn
Lighting Design and Production Design –  Baron Pugh
Costume and Wig Design – Ellie De Lucia
Sound Design – Sebastian Nixon

Online Playbill

July 11 – 20, 2025
Robinson Theatre
617 Lexington Street
Waltham, MA 02452

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

2 hours, 15 minutes with a 15-minute intermission

WALTHAM, Mass. — The musical Evita is having a moment. It is an interesting time for a resurgence of a play about a populist Argentine icon, when the world appears buffeted by the populist and authoritarian actions of some world leaders. 

The play, which started its Broadway run in 1979, is seeing a viral resurgence, thanks to a Rachel Zegler-led production in London that has taken some of its act outside the theater for the masses to enjoy. One would think that Eva Perón, the titular Argentine historical figure, would have appreciated the streetside stagecraft.  Continue reading →

May 05

Focusing on the Footnotes: FOUNDING F%#ERS, A World Premiere

Posted on by

Photo by Maggie Hall Photography.

Presented by Greater Boston Stage Company
A Don Fulton New Works Project
Written by Conor Casey
Director – Weylin Symes
Assistant Director/Choreographer – Tyler Rosati
Scenic Designer – Katy Monthei
Lighting Design – Corey Whittemore
Costume Design – Deidre Gerrard
Sound Design – Caroline Eng
Properties Master – Adelaide Majeski
Production Stage Manager – Marsha Smith
Fight Captain – Marge Dunn
Production Manager – Meghan Ward
Equity, Diversity & Inclusion Consultant – Kira Troilo, Art & Soul Consulting LLC

May 2 – May 18, 2025
Greater Boston Stage Company
395 Main Street
Stoneham, MA 02180

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

2 hours with a brief intermission

STONEHAM, Mass. —

Too often, history is presented as a straight line, especially when it comes to successful revolutionary moments in history. Think of the common perception of the Civil Rights movement; so often it is portrayed as a lone figure marching in a straight line to victory when, in reality, it was a coalition of competing voices and branches, with victories, defeats, missteps, and contradictions. This impulse to purge doubt and impose order on chaotic change sanctifies our view of these historical figures and movements, and obscures the messy work needed to make change. Continue reading →

Mar 31

When the Wheels Come Off: “The Play That Goes Wrong”

Posted on by

The cast. Photo via Greater Boston Stage Company.

Presented by Greater Boston Stage Company
Written by Henry Lewis, Henry Shields, and Jonathan Sayer
Director – Tyler Rosati
Original Scenic Design – Peter Colao
Scenic Design – Danielle Ibrahim
Lighting Design – Katie Whittemore
Costume Design – E. Rosser
Sound Design – James Cannon
Properties Master – David Allen Prescott
Intimacy/Violence Design – Samantha Richert
Production Stage – Manager Meghan Ward
Fight Captain – Sarah Morin

March 28 – April 19, 2025
Greater Boston Stage Company
395 Main Street
Stoneham, MA 02180

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

2 hours with a brief intermission

Some comic violence. May be too intense for young viewers.

STONEHAM, Mass. — Regular theatergoers quickly understand that live performance is a tightrope act, and the mind can wander to what can go wrong during lulls on stage. That may be why theatrical disasters are such fertile ground for stage comedy. To pull off such a play requires mastering the (sometimes nominal) source material and then acting at acting badly. Things can quickly get complicated, making the farce on stage sometimes something of a miracle to pull off.

The cast of the Greater Boston Stage Company’s The Play That Goes Wrong largely succeeds in this difficult task, creating chaos on stage that set the audience howling with laughter. The script provides a target-rich environment for comedy, and the energetic and committed cast capitalize on most of the opportunities provided. Continue reading →

Mar 27

Half-Baked Shakespeare: THE COMEDY OF HAMLET (A PREQUEL)

Posted on by

Presented by Reduced Shakespeare Company
Written and Directed by Reed Martin and Austin Tichenor
Backdrop Design: Tim Holstag
Costume Design: Freya Marcelius
Sound Design: Matthew Cowell and Zack Moore
Stage Manager: Elaine Randolph
Original Circus Music Composed by Peter Bufano; performed by Cirkestra
Starring Geoffrey Barnes, Doug Harvey, and Austin Tichenor

March 12 – 30, 2025
Merrimack Repertory Theatre
50 E Merrimack St
Lowell, MA 01852

Virtual playbill 

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

90 minutes with a 15-minute intermission

Some works on stage and film can grip you in the first moments and never let go. Shakespeare’s script for The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark is one such play. It is gripping even though a lot of nothing happens throughout most of it because of the titular character’s indecision. It is largely a pensive mood study, and the characters often dither to Seinfeldian levels.

Other works of stage and film can provide wall-to-wall action and frenetic energy and never capture your attention. This is the case with the Reduced Shakespeare Company’s production of The Comedy of Hamlet (a Prequel) playing at the Merrimack Repertory Theatre. It tries to add too many crowd-pleasing comedic elements but ends up feeling like a smoothie you keep tinkering with until the final taste is indistinguishable. Continue reading →

Nov 26

A Peek Inside the Funhouse of Our Minds: “Mindplay”

Posted on by

“Mindplay” photo by Chris Ruggiero.

Presented by the Huntington Theatre Company
Created by Vinny DePonto
Written by Vinny DePonto and Josh Koenigsberg
Director – Andrew Neisler
Scenic Design – Sibyl Wickersheimer
Lighting Design – Christopher Bowser
Sound Design – Kathy Ruvuna
Composer – Alex Harris

November 13 – December 1, 2024
Calderwood Pavilion
527 Tremont Street,
Boston, MA 02115

Critique by Craig Idlebrook

1.5 hours with no intermission

May be too intense for younger children

BOSTON — Towards the beginning of the intriguing one-man show Mindplay, mentalist Vinny DePonto was frank with the audience, telling them that the mind was easily manipulatable, and that he was good at doing it. DePonto was true to his word, as he mesmerized the audience with his quiet charm, sharp memory, and his apparent gift to read minds. However, the mentalist later attempted to mix frankness with artifice when he chose to tell his own story with a dazzling stage display as a prop, and this momentarily threatened to break the show’s spell. It may have been his greatest trick to still create a captivating theatrical experience despite this misstep. Continue reading →

Oct 08

The Subjectiveness of Sanity: “The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe”

Posted on by

Photo by Meg Moore/megpix.com; Kathryn Van Meter as Trudy.

Presented by Merrimack Repertory Theatre
Written by Jane Wagner
Directed by Courtney Sale
Featuring Kathryn Van Meter

October 2-20, 2024
Nancy L. Donahue Theatre at Liberty Hall
50 E. Merrimack St.
Lowell, MA

Online Playbill

Run Time: approx. 2 hours 25 minutes including one 15-minute intermission

Please note the following content advisories: Adult Language, Death by Suicide, Suicide Ideation, Drug Use, Sexual Violence

Review by Craig Idlebrook

LOWELL, Mass. — There is a tightrope act-feel to a one-person show, as audiences can become painfully aware there is nowhere for the performer to hide, or even catch a breath. Flubbed lines, low energy, or a lack of connection to the source material can lead to a long night for both actor and audience.

Luckily for the audience of Merrimack Repertory Theater’s The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe, Kathryn Van Meter (Trudy) deftly dodges all potential pitfalls of a solo performer. She works hand-in-hand within the exquisite source material provided by playwright Jane Wagner for us to see the interconnectedness between an off-kilter woman living on the streets and the universe. Continue reading →