Forseth and Alvarez; Photo by Benjamin Rose Photography.

Presented by Boston Playwrights’ Theatre
by KJ Moran Velz
Directed by Elaine Vaan Hogue
Digital Playbill 

October 9-26, 2025
Boston Playwrights’ Theatre
949 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston, MA 02215
Content transparency: Mother Mary contains scenes of sexual intimacy and references to abortion. For more: https://www.bostonplaywrights.org/ct/mother-mary

This critique contains light spoilers. 

BOSTON — Mary, known then by her Hebrew name Miriam, Mother of Yeshua, was a Jewish woman of color knocked up with a baby she didn’t want and set to marry a man she didn’t know (Biblically or platonically) in the Ancient Middle East. We’re told Yusuf married her anyway. Then they immigrated to Jerusalem, where Miriam delivered her son in a barn surrounded by pooping farm animals. If you replace Jerusalem with Southie and the donkey with a taxi, you get a summary of Mother Mary. Sort of. 

This summary borrows from the play’s summary on the BPT website. Mother Mary is based loosely on the Biblical myth of Mary, Jesus, and Joseph. Taxi driver Jo Cruz (Adriana Alvarez) knows the streets of 1968’s Southie like the back of her hand, but no road map can prepare her for meeting Mary O’Sullivan (Tara Forseth), a Catholic school teacher with a boyfriend and a very strict mother. Despite rising tensions between their Puerto Rican and Irish communities, Jo and Mary find themselves in an unexpectedly close friendship…or is it something more? But their growing connection takes a turn when Mary asks Jo to take her on a risky road trip during a snowstorm from which there’s no going back.  Continue reading →